ofcourse it is down to how safe you feel knowing your tires possibly arent as grippy as they once were, but i dont think theyre going to suddenly lose all their friction and send you off the road, chances are youre probably used to exactly how much grip your car has under pretty much all circumstances with the tires you have now. i have one old tire on my car, as i couldnt afford four new tires, and my spare had never been used, so i swapped it onto the car (i got the car when it was off the road, the previous owner had completely bald tires on it just so it could be moved if necesary). the only trouble i've had with it is that it's worn down more than twice as fast as the other three, and that it's now starting to slip a bit under heavy braking cos the tread is almost at the markers for replacement time. i dont know what year that tire is, ill post back after i check it. basically what i'm saying, is my experience with old tires is varied, my sigma tires are a good 10 years old and theyre grippy as anything and look perfect, that spare on the niki is likely to be a similar age, but it wore down really fast, my ex girlfriend's car had old tires on it which looked perfect, but they were slippery as anything and had to be replaced.
which is why i said if youre happy with your stopping distance etc, then keep them, because perhaps after ~5 years the manufacturers own standards kick in, rather than the legal standards.
i'm all for safety though, dont get me wrong, i'm not saying you should go out driving on bald tires, but if your tires still do their job properly and have working (and legal) tread, then i dont see a problem.