For it to be running that rich I'd suspect either flooding of the carb or as you said you carb is close to original, perhaps the jets are too big.
My air mixture screw just adjusts the idle mixture.
Check the float level first.
On bikes we use a piece of clear hose pushed-on to the drain, one holds the clear hose up to the side of the carb and it gives the level.
On my Air cooled I did as the manual said
