ive only ever used a rubber gasket, but i would image them to be better than cork as they quash better. plus cork does eventualy dissintergrate, (not what you want in your rocker gear and oil)
other thing i was thinking is stretched/damaged threads not holding the rocker cover down properly, but you said the actualy gasket is damaged so would suggest it must be over tightening,
nothing more irritating than a leaky rocker cover, as David Mcneice (126cab) always says alot of oil looks alot.
regards
Chris