Well I *did* give up my TV licence about three years ago, and you know what? Life carried on pretty much as usual. I spent the money I saved on a licence to get DVDs of things I actually *wanted* to watch, and for anything else I used iPlayer and the other channels' equivalents.
There's no danger at all of missing anything good, because whenever anything of any quality appears, there is bound to be general discussion from friends/on the web etc along the lines of "did you see...? It was fantastic", and then you simply go to iPlayer to check it out. So everyone else filters out all the garbage for you, at their own cost in time, and you can focus on the good bits - of which there are lamentably few these days, witness the recent Comic Relief evening which was made up largely of sketches from sit coms and the like that were popular when I was a callow youth, decades ago.
I saw Clarkson in person many aeons ago now, at the NEC motor show, and he was a completely moronic tosser even then. I don't know what it is about the BBC, they seem to specialise in making multi-billionaires out of complete nonentities with no apparent intellect whatsoever - Chris Moyles, Chris Evans, Russell Brand, Jonathan Ross. To listen to these people speaking you wonder if they can actually read and write, they come across as little better than ignorant thugs. Allegedly. As for talent, please let me know if you ever find any.
As for a replacement host for the programme, I would sign the petition for Alan Partridge if I could find it on-line.