Club126UK

Fiat 126 Chat => Fiat 126 Chat => Topic started by: Bruce on May 07, 2006, 07:01:18 PM

Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Bruce on May 07, 2006, 07:01:18 PM
the smart car is hailed as a great inovation in small cars, but for a fraction of the price you could buy a Bis. both have similar performance and economy, both have rear engines under the floor with rear wheel drive, but the smart allways looks as if would topple backward when driving up hill and pull wheelies on the flat!!! despite being slightly shorter than the 126 it has a larger turning circle. both have front and rear luggage compartments, the smart has more luggage room but then the 126 has 4 seats, 2 of which can be folded down, when the rear seats are folded down in the Fiat it can carry more than the Smart when it is a single seater while still having 2 seats. as to the overall size of the cars, the Fiat may be 607mm longer than the Smart, but the smart is 138mm wider and 206mm shorter. so the 126 can carry more luggage or passengers than the Smart, turn inside the Smart, get through smaller gaps, get under lower bridges and is only a little bit longer. these drawings are to scale so you can see the difference:
(http://www.bruces-stuff.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/126vsmart.jpg)
as are these photos of the 2 cars;
(http://www.bruces-stuff.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/126vsmart2.jpg)
the Fiat is a small car that is fun to drive, the Smart looks strange and needs a computer to stop it falling over. So i ask you who's the smart car now?
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: 126dave on May 07, 2006, 08:54:51 PM
bruce,great presentation,but your preaching to the wrong peeps..............anyway,its all about sales and marketing,for example,why does anyone need anything else but a morris minor (the '60s version)? availible in all the needed body types..........or a CD? come to think of it why do we need plastic wraps on everything???.

it would also be nice if car makers gave the figure of energy (barrels of oil?) that go into making todays so called eco freindly cars,what with all the ceramics/carbon/alloys and stainless steel etc etc that are now needed to run these hot runnig computerised cars
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: fiatfsm on May 07, 2006, 09:25:40 PM
this is right up my street, last autumn my wife and I went for a test drive in a Smart... it was a gorgeous day so we took the 126 down to the dealer, the sales staff were all over it needless to say. Anyway, off we went in the Smart, within minutes my wife felt sick as the motion of those things is akin to a small boat, the characterful 3 pot engine sounded like a washing machine on self destruct spin, the understeer was phenomenal, when it hit a bump in the road it just hopped about the place... and that gearchange is woefully bad, no really it is just plain crap. What a dreadful little heap those things are, we bought a used MR2 instead!! Soon as I got back into the 126 I realised what a great small car should be like. Also from what Ive heard from smart owners the general reliability makes even the BIS sound great! If it was 4k tops then OK, I could get it, just but it costs as much as a real car. Agree with the comment re Minors, I drive a 92 Panda as my everyday car and it has nothing extra on it, wonderfully simple motoring.
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: paul harbinson. on May 08, 2006, 07:53:40 AM
Don't let everyone know but their engines explode after a few years of ownership.You only have to look at the sticker on my engine cover to know the contempt I hold for the "city car" that is the dumb (sorry smart).Is that a bit harsh or am I telling the truth?Put it this way how much are smarts 7-8k.Why when loose change will get you a cracking 126 that holds four.By the way the smart 4four will stop production soon due to poor sales.Daimler-Chrysler are trying to sell smart as its costing the company a fortune and there is talk of the Chinese buying the rights to build the smart roadster and calling it an mg midget. :shock:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Bruce on May 08, 2006, 09:19:04 AM
Paul, is this the sticker you have on yours:
(http://www.fiat126.co.uk/images/P1010380.jpg)
where can you get them, and do they do it in black as my car is white?
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: paul harbinson. on May 08, 2006, 01:03:15 PM
yup,thats the one.I got the picture of the the links part of the site then,got an apprentice to make me the sticker....I have a spare one :D
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Chris Lakin on May 08, 2006, 09:49:22 PM
what a great demo there Bruce, perfectly illustrted reasons to buy a 126 and not a SMART
 :lol:

youre right though, 4 seats or 2 seats?, same size car? same engine size (but without the turbo)   and of course 126 has better looks. :lol:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: gregs656 on May 10, 2006, 07:26:09 PM
this is all true

but remember, in a smart car, the cumple zone isnt your face!
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: dajwid on May 10, 2006, 07:32:10 PM
We don't crash our cars, thank you very much. We love and cherish them :lol:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: gregs656 on May 10, 2006, 07:47:16 PM
:lol:

and race them  :shock:  :shock:  :cool:  :cool:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: 126dave on May 10, 2006, 08:57:12 PM
oh yes....we race them..................good point on crumpling your face tho,would'nt fancy takin it from the side either.....................great cars,but '70s tech.but if i was to give my step daughter either of these choices for reg travel? id give her a smart....but with the choice of ragging my aircooled at the weekend!............
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: issylupus on September 18, 2006, 09:41:33 PM
God, I cant stand the SMART, they look like a kids drawing that never got finished.
The people who drive them are just waisting their money. I bet in 10 to 15 years you wont find many of them still running about on the roads.
They will be filed in the same drawer as the Sinclair C5 and the rubix cube.
I was stuck behind one old lady who couldnt drive to save herself. She must have thought if she had a wee car she wouldnt be noticed as much. How wrong she was. She clogged up the traffic in both directions in Bently for over 10 minuets trying to park the thing in a space I could have got my bus in !!! After hitting the kerb 4 times she pulled out and attempted the manouver in reverse which was just as bad. when she finaly got it remotley close to the kerb enough to let the trafic by she waved politley as if we had all just done her a favour or something. I was now 15 minuets late on a twenty minuet run.

Get them off the road and make more room for a proper small car (the 126,)
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Chris Lakin on September 18, 2006, 10:22:11 PM
ouch dangerous ground there Issy, its pistols at dawn!!!  ive just had an email from the Smart Car Club Chairman wanting to settle it over a race.

hahah only kidding  :lol:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: issylupus on September 19, 2006, 08:38:32 PM
bring it on !!!!

I'll give them a race any day.
but if its an endurance race they want then I bet my wee car will still be running in another 5 years.

WILL THEIR'S ???????

If it's pistols at dawn then remember I use to do a lot of shooting when I lived in Scotland.

Nothing will change my mind, I still think the SMART looks like a wedge of cheese without the crackers !!!!
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: paul harbinson. on September 20, 2006, 07:52:44 AM
I love it when a smart stops behind me.You can see them straining to see what the picture is on my engine cover and then when it dawns on them the look of disgust is priceless :lol: .It  usually ends in a race after that.I win most of the time,not from straight speed but the point that I'm not afraid to chuck mine in and out of traffic or into a corner :wink:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Chris Lakin on September 20, 2006, 12:56:48 PM
hahaha  :lol:

that made me laugh
Quote
"You can see them straining to see what the picture is on my engine cover and then when it dawns on them the look of disgust is priceless "


Paul i made this thread  sticky (so it sits at the top) because i thought Bruce had done well at comparing the two, i like to see old cars compared with modern.

Chris
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: fiatfsm on September 20, 2006, 06:03:49 PM
good to see this thread still going! :D
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: paul harbinson. on September 22, 2006, 07:48:42 AM
Chris,only noticing this now but is that an early Lancia Beta saloon behind your air cooled 126?
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Chris Lakin on September 22, 2006, 10:31:52 AM
hi paul, no i think that one is a gamma??, which belongs to Andy Collins who i bought that aircooled from has about 16 cars, and funny enough not long after that pic was taken he went and bought a MK1 Beta Saloon, the owner was a builder and was about to use it as an everyday winter car  :???:  Its a stunning looking car with no rust!! Andy owns a a few Beta's.

regards

Chris
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Bruce on September 22, 2006, 06:26:05 PM
we have quite a lot of Smarts around here, i cant wait to get my bis back on the road (probably won't be till next year now as i am moving very soon) so i can drive up to a smart and see the drivers face when he/she looks down and sees a smaller car especially if it had 4 peps in it  :D
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: bis13 on September 23, 2006, 10:43:35 PM
the reason the smart is called so is for one reason . every time their owners set eyes on them they feel that sting caused by all that wasted money. i quite like them they make me laugh and driving one is a hoot as they are so bad.
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: 126dave on September 24, 2006, 09:36:38 AM
there is one locally with full Brabus mods......i know the guy,he loves it,very very quick and handles well......he has spent nearly M series Beemer money tho on it.............. :)
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: stuey on September 27, 2006, 09:09:44 PM
better hope this guys doesnt read this thread....


(http://www.ananova.com/images/web/743903.jpg)
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Chris Lakin on September 27, 2006, 11:13:31 PM
hahaha, thats cooool

i think the smart wins it on this battle,
(http://www.lolcars.com/images/fiat-126p-monster-truck.jpg) this 126 isnt quite as impressive.  :???:

Chris
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Paulh81 on May 05, 2007, 02:30:36 PM
As i was reading this post i was wondering if we could put some other small cars into the subject

For example: the good old faithful Mini. I cant decide which car to buy as ive just passed my test im 21, and im drawen between the Fiat 126 and the Mini.

Oh and by the way i wouldnt be seen dead in a Smart!




HELP ME BUY A 126 Please!!
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: nathan126 on May 05, 2007, 02:48:48 PM
For a first car, buying a 126 is the better move. If you find one then it'll probably be in a far better condition than the mini in the price range you are looking at. To get a good mini you'll be looking at a couple of thousand pounds, and its hard to get a solid 998cc one with minimal rust. (I have to admit, i was torn between a 126 and mini also, but i chose the 126 purely for the fact that they have become so rare, and they, in my opinion, have more character).
Also with a mini you'd be looking at the 848/998 variants, and you'll have to be careful on what model you buy because as this will be your first car - a lower insurance group is better.

You can go to this website:
http://www.abi.org.uk/carinsurance/default.asp

And it has a list of all UK cars' insurance groups.

(You'll see that all 126's are group one - the lowest)  :lol:

I'm sure you'll see whats better for the first car  :lol:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Paulh81 on May 05, 2007, 02:59:50 PM
I would prefer a 126 to be honest as they do have more character, pluss there are loads of minis knocking about.

Only problem is... i cant find one! i live in clitheroe lancashire, i cant find 1 anywhere local. i suppose im gunna have to travel!

by the way, ive seen a cracking little Fiat amigo campervan 900cc on Ebay!    WANT IT WANT IT WANT IT!
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: phreak97 on July 14, 2007, 02:12:11 AM
i havnt driven a mini or a smart.. but i have got a morris 1100 s which is basically a four door mini with a 1275cc cooper s engine, and while it is a great car, and i spent alot of time and money making it work, i still think the 126 is hugely more fun to drive. the morris has character too, but the 126 is "cute" and nothing gets peoples attention as much as that. plus a 126 actually seems to get more female attention than other cars because of the cuteness.. girls die for cuteness.
i make myself sound bad there, i just want to clarify that i have only been with one girl in my life and im still with her. i am judging by her reaction and that of my female friends and people who my friend and i have come accross on our travels.

also, minis use more petrol. and my morris definately does, though it is still great for consumption.

buy an isetta:P
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: gorilly on August 06, 2007, 01:57:10 PM
for character the 126 is great but i bet if all of you were given a 126 and told to drive it 100 miles everyday, not on motorway but round residential streets you'd all be begging for a smart after less than a week!
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: bis13 on August 06, 2007, 02:18:38 PM
want to bet? i did when i lived in london and driving around bus queues on a rainy monday morning on the pavement is a hoot , or gunning it down one way streets the wrong way , or taking short cuts through southwark park on the footpaths ...i better stop for risk of getting into trouble . :lol:
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: phreak97 on August 06, 2007, 02:28:14 PM
i'd still go for a 126. i dont get uncomfortable at all.. i have done a ~2000km road trip in one, and i'd do it again. stuff the smart, i bet it'd be more uncomfortable anyway.
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Paulh81 on August 11, 2007, 04:32:37 PM
Got a 126 Bis! white and in really good nick.. i mean good too £475
Title: 126 v Smart
Post by: Bruce on September 06, 2007, 11:41:51 PM
another car has been introduced to add to the fight, this one is a 4 seater; the Mitsubishi i,

it is realy clever and inovative (not), to save space and make the car smaller on the outside they have moved the 659cc engine to under the boot floor.

all this inovation (or should that be coppying) has produced a car that is stiil way bigger than a 126, it is even bigger than the latest bigger (longer) Smart 4 2, which I believe is even longer than a 126 possibly even with its bumpers on.
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Hazey-n-Marc on April 12, 2012, 11:50:29 PM
My neighbours have a shart car, they cannot walk past our 126 without admiring it. They have only had it 3 months and it has had 700 plus spent in repairs. They are not good cars. The 126 probably isn't the most reliable, most comfortable or most capable of cars, but it is cheap and easy to repair, economical, a quite unexpected babe magnet (and nostalgic older person magnet), bloody good fun and as cute as you like.
No contest!

Marc
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: ypsilon_lancar on April 13, 2012, 07:13:14 PM
I had both a Smart Roadster and a 126 at the same time. I have to say that the Smart was fantastic! The Fortwo I agree isnt very 'smart' but the Roadster is a different animal altogether, it really captures the spirit of the Triumph Spitfire / MG Midget etc etc.
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Hazey-n-Marc on April 13, 2012, 07:18:04 PM
The roadster is a different thing though, it isn't a sensible city car. If I had the money and space and couldn't find a toyota 800, or a honda S500, S600, S800,  I might be tempted by the roadster.
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Kent126 on April 16, 2012, 03:19:15 PM
I drove my ex girlfriends uncles shart car a few years ago. It was the second worst car I had ever driven! (Worst was the Rover 25).

You couldn't pay me to have one!

126 all the way. The only problem with modern engineering and european emissions and safety regulations is that no car company could ever make a car the size of an old mini or 126 nowadays. It would never pass any safety tests.

Anyway, imagine having a crash in this;

(http://i152.photobucket.com/albums/s191/thomasrenshaw/blue_p50.jpg)

Peel P50. Only 50 ever made in the late 60's, and rarer than rocking horse poo. There is a rusty one for sale that needs restoration for £25,000. Good ones fetch about £40,000.

Tom
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: ypsilon_lancar on April 16, 2012, 09:06:59 PM

126 all the way. The only problem with modern engineering and european emissions and safety regulations is that no car company could ever make a car the size of an old mini or 126 nowadays. It would never pass any safety tests.

Tom

This aint far off the size etc. What are peoples general view on the Nano, I think its quite a good modern attempt at a real peoples car
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Hazey-n-Marc on April 16, 2012, 09:19:16 PM
Looks horrible though.
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Funkin Go-nut on April 17, 2012, 12:26:28 AM
Dont forget the G-wiz...

http://www.goingreen.co.uk/store/content/lovegwiz

Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: popik81 on April 17, 2012, 09:45:14 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Le-ksimMkJ4

:)
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: 1973/126 on April 17, 2012, 02:19:15 PM
 I wish I haven`t watched that video. It`s only driving now in a crash helmet.
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: popik81 on April 17, 2012, 09:59:08 PM
i think helmet can't help you   :D
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Bar Vitelli on April 17, 2012, 10:22:00 PM
This is nice though...

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Mini-Moke-Look-a-Like-Foulkes-Impala-based-on-Fiat-500-126-/150799320740?pt=Automobiles_UK&hash=item231c5706a4
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: popik81 on April 17, 2012, 10:24:26 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iKGfo1wmOM&feature=related

and smart
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: 1973/126 on April 25, 2012, 04:13:38 PM
 I`m really not a fan of the Smart car, but wouldn`t say no to this one! Loving the stickers ;D

 http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/180868759798?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_3873wt_1185
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Kent126 on April 25, 2012, 07:36:46 PM
Smart cars are poo. Period.

Oh and Ladislav, if you ever buy one I am coming down to yours and setting fire to it! You have been warned!

Tom
Title: Re: 126 v Smart
Post by: Hazey-n-Marc on April 25, 2012, 07:38:57 PM
This is the real badge