Club126UK

Fiat 126 Chat => Fiat 126 Chat => Topic started by: fixit on April 23, 2013, 11:37:30 PM

Title: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: fixit on April 23, 2013, 11:37:30 PM
 i'm struggling with deciding on a welder gas or gas less mig
I thought id cracked it, then read: mark the welder, classic car, and an article in landrover mag and a mig forum, and each give conflicting advice or far too much info which confuses further, ( I was a non mig  gas welder but don't have access to that kit
so taking into account of all info I seem to need a mig welder that can be
run off house mains,
a torch that not permanent live (has a switch action), not keen on electric shocks
 can weld body work,
has a wire speed selector switch and weld power setting
 it has to be able to be used outdoors in a windy garden, no protection from elements (I wont be using in wet weather)
and not suffer from wire bird nesting.
be reliable for this project.
will it be gas or gas less???

 so what do you fellow restorers use or recommend?
 
regards fixit

 
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: kev126 on April 24, 2013, 12:01:40 AM
I guy I know who fully restores Minis uses a Sealey SuperMig 180. It's probably best to spend a little more money on a decent welder because the more expensive ones ARE better! And always gas. I think the non-gas arc welders are known to just be crap.
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: dajwid on April 24, 2013, 07:04:16 AM
I am really new to this but I know this will open a real can of worms.

I have a very good arc welder, it does the job fine. For bodywork you really need a MIG it is easy to learn. Gas or gassless, you will get a better finish with gas, but for a couple of small diy jobs gassless will be OK.

Buy the best Mig you can afford, as all the articles say, as for Mig welding in the wind, all that happens is you won't have any sheilding gas and end up with a mess, but you could just put something up the sheild you from the wind.

I am sure plenty of more experienced people can give advise.

(this weekend I welded a repair section on my dash board with m trusty old Clarke 190 arc welder, it looks OK)
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: thepuddlejumper on April 24, 2013, 12:53:45 PM
Hi I use a 180 mig with gas, it has the option to go gas less but I don't fancy that.  If you weld outside you should use a screen to prevent anyone looking in and getting a flash, painful, also to keep the weld area shrouded in gas or it will just spatter and not weld.  To get the best results buy the best you can afford.  You will need to find a gas supplier if you intend to do a lot of welding as the larger bottles are much cheaper in the long run, the small bottles don't last a jot.  Hope this helps.

Ralph
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: Rusty's Uncle on April 24, 2013, 05:32:33 PM
I have just been looking into Mig welders myself but there are so many out there on the internet. I can't find any local suppliers to go & have a look & a chat. So recomendations are useful as I don't want to end up with some mickey mouse  item. I was thinking about a gasless model that uses the flux coated wire but I read one review that said you get a lot of splatter with these so it is hard to see exactly what is going on at the weld compared to the gas models. So reckon it will be gas at least.
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: wsmitwil on April 24, 2013, 05:49:33 PM

Don't get a gas less one I've got one and it's c*** very weak not really good enough for car work
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: kev126 on April 24, 2013, 06:03:49 PM
So I think we've summed it up -


I've gotta get one now!
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: grubscrew on April 24, 2013, 06:35:50 PM
 Having been through the crap welders , I too can say gasless are not used in industry for obvious reasons, any way what you save on gas you pay for on special wire. They are only ok if you are using in windy conditions as there is no gas to get blown away.
   I use a MUREX Tradesmig 171, and is a brilliant bit of kit, with variable wire speed/thickness of metal and weld timer for spot welding, all together with a "Euromig" torch. Its on casters and takes the slightly larger bottle of Argon/Co2 mix, available from your local ADAMS Gas dealer. Although its best plugged into a 16amp socket (blue plug), you can run it on a 13 amp, as Ive never maxed it out.
  There are MUREX dealers through out the UK. Avoid the hobby welders, although ok for odd work from time to time, go one step up, its worth it. Mike.
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: dajwid on April 24, 2013, 10:32:32 PM
(I use a MUREX Tradesmig 171), I agree a great welder but sadly it costs as much as my 126 is worth  ;D

Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: Tate on April 25, 2013, 04:37:21 AM
Go for a gas welder! Gas less welders are a joke if you are going to use the welder for cars. I wouldn't choose the cheapest because they are usually crap. A good welder will last for decades.


I use Migatronic Automig 180 and it is perfect!

(http://www.nettivaraosat.fi/images/kuvat/M79100001_migatronic_automig183.jpg)
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: stuey on April 25, 2013, 07:26:45 AM
Agree pretty much with whats being said here- get a gassed mig welder (gasless wire is crap) I have a machine mart clarke 130 and Its served me well for 15 years now but if I have the choice I would at least make sure its got a euro torch (mine doesnt) and it has wheels (I had to buy a seperate cart for mine) and can support a big bottle (essential if you are doing a resto- nothing worse than running out of gas on a sunday afternoon!)
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: fixit on April 27, 2013, 02:29:07 AM
thank you all for your helpful advice  ;D sorry for delay in reply

 mig gas welder it will be

thought  narrowed the mig choice down to around max 185 - 200amps min 20amps - 30, to a Sealey, Murex, Migatronix, Clarke, Portamig or Oxford,  but then a spanner flew, and put me totally off course,

 migs are fairly easy to order online, unlike finding a good local gas and wire supplier, once I get me voice back, going to make some calls before making final choice then ordering
bah heck

my neighbours are sheep, quite nosey and are outstanding in their field, ;D
 I will make a fireproof screen before the local baaa sight authority looks me up. these ewes don't have pink coats.. unlike the ones in Scotland.

while gathering intel I came across this post, from Teflon the pictures could help fellow restorer welders..

http://www.lro.com/forum3/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=34568

 thank you again for help so far
regards f


Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: Lloyd74 on April 29, 2013, 08:58:22 AM
Iv'e got a clarke (Machine Mart) 150te turbo had it 6yrs GAS and with this ive restored a Rover P5 using about ? kilometers of wire? only had to replace the wire feed wheel in all that time, down to how much use and it gets used most days. Ive put roofs on cars and thousands of other things Ive got a stick inverter and a TIG as well all of which I use regularly.
Ensure you use a gas MIG as gassless are various expletives and for automotove applications run it on 0.6mm wire as the thin stuff is 1mm and it reduces the blow through hold the torch at 45 degrees to the seam to effectively increase the thickness of the metal use the lowest power setting required to give effective penetration and dont forget that wire feed speed will also effect the power as well as suit your speed. You can use Co2 but co2/argon Argoshield is LOADS better giving a tidy result, most little bottles don't last long so buy the 110ltr ones their more expensive but last loads longer. When the weld quality degrades it may be down to spatter in the torch shroud which must be kept clean as it must be insulated from the current and the build up of spatter inside it links the shroud to the electrode also the tips wear as the wire passes through so make sure you have spares as this causes bird poo welds. Always cut right back to good metal and always make a good earth connection!
Hope this helps! LLLLLLLOYD!
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: fixit on May 22, 2013, 11:36:13 PM
well
I finally went for a Clarke
the main reason was comsumable parts would be easy to locate
 and the cost, I joined the email club beginning of year, machine mart just sent me a vat free one use code which meant I could get a better welder for less money
I finally sourced gas around 25 miles away using the recommended www.adamsgas.co.uk locator although the sites locator wouldn't link to suppliers site, so ended up ringing
argon mixed co2 rent free bottle hobby gas, is £91.00 for the initial bottle inc gas
 then any refill swap is around £30 the bottle is about 75cm by 15cm
thank you all for your helpful advise  ;D
regards f
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: Lloyd74 on May 25, 2013, 10:09:46 PM
I love welding, it's actually simple once you get through the myth just practice 1st on scraps and get used to your machine using a mig is the simplest way to achieve great results
Enjoy and message me if you get stuck!
LLLLLoyd
Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: fixit on May 25, 2013, 10:38:20 PM
thanks for the offer ;D  the kettles always on
still preparing Freddie at the moment, I want to make the rear middle panel then I will have some cut offs to practice with
although im thinking of making a shelter to work in with this strange weather we having

I must admit ive put the .6 mm wire in, and threaded though the torch, wired in a massive plug, (destructions said so)  got friendly with the shroud and tips
gave the bodywork a polish so it had the wet look hehehe
just need to sort fire extinguisher, and googles for the outstanding neighbours ;D
regards f

Title: Re: Which mig welder gas or gas less
Post by: Ruggero58 on July 06, 2013, 04:32:43 PM
Good Choice.   For years I had an Italian made Deca welder and I ran a CO2 Argon mix also.  I bought it used for $50 from a Autobody shop that was upgrading.  I set it up with the finest(skinnyest) wire I could buy for it.   I could weld tin foil with that thing! ...almost...  The big thing is minimal heat means minimal warping.   Tack your panels first then do the full weld and that should keep your warping to zero.   Ciao for now...