Club126UK
Fiat 126 Chat => Fiat 126 Mechanical Problem Solving => Topic started by: neil 126 on November 13, 2010, 11:52:01 PM
-
I know there has been a thread going about starter motors recently but i have been looking for over 2 hours and i can,t find it.
I have been having trouble with starting recently.
I have had the starter off a few times, cleaned the comutators and bushes and the starter motor now turns very freely and is nice and strong.
The gear has been cleened and slides on the shaft freely and does not stick.
I have checked all connections, power and earth to the body, taken them back to clean metal and reasembled.
The problem that i have is that the solenoid is not working.
It does not pull the plunger in and force the starter gear on the motor into the teeth on the flywheel.
I have had the solenoid seperated from the starter and cleaned all contacts but still nothing.
My understanding is that the solenoid is nothing more than an elecromagnet that operates when charged at startup only, given this what could have failed on it.
I have tried to open it up to investigate but it looks like there may be need for some serious soldering equipment for this.
-
When you start the car, is there a clicking sound?
-
well if u want to send it to me ill look inside the solenoid and replace the contacts , thats what i do for a job
-
Hi guys, thanks for the responce.
There is no clicking from the solenoid or starter.
The starter does turn (very fast, now that i have cleaned up the contacts), and i am able to start the car( only on about the 4 or 5th attempt) but i think that the gear on he starter only moves along the shaft due to its momentum on the slow down, and it only just makes it into the teath on the flywheel.
Is it something that i can fix?, I do have soldering kit but it is only a small hobby thing. I can get a better one off a neighbour if needed.
I may take you up on your offer (hobbs126) if i can not do it myself.
What would your terms be?
-
After my near death experience this morning as the car ran me over as i tried to push start and slipped on ice. i have decided to by a new one from 126FAN i have also ordered a few other service spairs.
Thanks guys for your offer of help, but today was the last straw and i had to do something.
I may well trie and fix the old one but need something quick.
The weather is getting cold up hear and i dont fancy having to push start the car in the ice again.
P.S. I don't hink anyone saw me as i was laid on the ground as the drivers door ran me over and squashed me to the ground.
-
Neil , I loved your story but if you were a modern man you would have captured your near demise on your mobile and posted it on that "Tube" thing for us all to enjoy ;D
Could be that your car has got it in for you :oops:
Just a theory but don't get all solenoid about it [-/
-
I think it is safe to say that i am definately not one of these modern men.
What is this "tube " thing that you talk of. and for mobile phones, mine spends most of its time switched off with the battery flat in the top drawer of the bed side table, and it certainly does not take pictures.
I am glad though that there was nobody to see, as if there was, it would be a prime candidate for Jerremy Beadle's You've been framed.
Is that still going?
You tend to loose touch when you don't have a telly.
Still, it did make for a nice change. The tedium and drudgery of my monotonous work life was somehow brocken as a result.
Better to laugh than cry.
-
Hi Neil
Glad someone else is struggling with their Fiat in the ice (not glad you're struggling specially but you know what i mean!) I had to de-ice mine this morning for the first time...am seriously thinking about not taking him out in the winter.
I am having problems starting too, after 4th or 5th attempt it starts but sometimes when I turn the ignition there is just a clicking sound as if nothing is happening but as I say eventually he starts. Am worried that in a while he will just refuse to start...
Mhairi
-
Hi Mhairi, if when you turn the key you just get a click it means that the ignition power is getting to the starter motor but the solenoid is not kicking in. Might be worth getting battery connections and all earth points checked out. If you still have the problem then you may need a new starter or solenoid. The 126fan guys are doing a new solenoid for 23 euros. On their site it is in the Electricity section , page 9 & described as "Starter Electromagnetic Coil" T65 27. If you go that way I would also go for a pair of new brushes described as "Starter Carbon" at 1.2 euros each [-/
-
Thanks Rusty...great advice. It's going back to the garage on Monday so they can check the new engine over so will ask them to have a look...will note down what you say and ask them for their advice!
m
-
O.K. I've done my best and it still isn't working.
I have replaced the solenoid and it's no better.
Bloody electrics >:(
Just to fill you in, the starter turns nice and hard but the solenid is not activating.
Any and all help appreciated.
-
Have you checked that there is 12v on the small wire that connects to the solenoid when you turn the ignition to the start position ???
-
my car wont turn over, but i can bump start it. if when the engine is running i pull the starter lever the starter will engage, then i will be able to start the engine directly after turning it off, is this likley to be anything to do with the starter solenoid?
Jeremy
-
Pull the lever?
Dude thats not a solenoid.
Get a piece of wood and push on the lever by hand, you may find you cable is not pulling the lever enough
-
yeah I'd already figured that out (the cable broke the day after i bought the car). this is something else.
-
so is there no solenoid on the older ones?
i was just pulling the lever by hand from underneath, that could have resulted in a bit of a shock. :o quite literaly.
-
I think that Darrell is suffering from nicotine withdrawal symtoms :o
You do not wanna be pulling on that starter lever when the engine is running as you will knacker your starter motor bendix and starter ring. :oops:
If you can only bump start the car then the starter motor will work then it it could be a couple of things. Loose fan belt so little charge in battery, poor battery condition , Poor earth & battery connections all the way through & finally worn starter motor.
You do not have a solenoid. On the later cars the solenoid does the work of the earlier pull switch [-/
-
NIcotine withdrawal has got bugger all to do with it.
It happens to mine from time to time that the starter is a bit stiff to engage and needs that extra force to get it to crank hence I say try a piece of WOOD to avoid shock etc to apply the extra force.
And yes I was replying to your post where you said ' is this likley to be anything to do with the starter solenoid?'
If it works sometimes and not others, specifically after the unadvisable engagement of the starter when the engine is running, I dont see how the battery condition earth and fan belt can have anything to do with it.
Perhaps a qualified mechanic will be the best cure...now there's a bit of nicotine withdrawal!
-
Could also be the connector under the button on the starter (the copper one with the thread coming out to which the leads are connected to) that is worn and doesn't connect properly. If you're lucky it might be worn on one side and can be turned over.
-
OK let's break it down into smaller chunks . If the battery is starting to fail & this is the time of year for it then it may not pack the punch to turn over the starter motor. If any of the connections in the main power circuit are poor then the starter motor may not work. So you have battery connection to earth on the main frame , battery lead to the starter motor and I have encountered bad corrosion at the starter switch connection in the past. Then the earth strap back to the main frame. A slightly loose fan belt , especialy if you are running an alternator , will produce enough power to put out the ignition light but not enough to recharge the battery. A short run after a bump start could well just trickle enough juice into the battery to energise the starter.
When you pull the starter lever it brings two large copper contacts together. If they do not meet properly & are worn or if the cable is not well adjusted they will arc and further damage the contact faces and you are on a downward slope. That is why , if you use a piece of wood , you can get more force on the starter switch lever than you can with the cable & starter lever. If you use a metal push rod & connect with the main power terminal on the starter you will short out the battery to earth very easily and produce a bit of a light show but you ain't gonna get electrocuted with 12 volts .
I use my silver capped walking cane with the rubber foot on such occaisions ;D
-
I use my silver capped walking cane with the rubber foot on such occaisions ;D
Like Dr. House huh? ;D
-
There you go, buy a new battery new starter, new cables and a piece of wood.
Funny still my point has not reached home.
SOmetimes the mesh of the starter doesnt quite line up for some odd reason I havnt quite figured-out. The battery can be brand new as mine is and fully charged but a little more force will be required.
-
:D you can't mess with the mesh :o
It is all lined up. If the bendix does not align with the starter ring then you have major problems :oops:
If you have very worn parts in that department then the starter motor can jam. Then you have to put the car in gear & try & push it to & fro until it releases :)
As GTMaster says the copper bolt can be rotated to get a good contact as a short term fix [-/
Dr House is a lightweight in the stick department , I save my ebony diamond encrusted wand for special occaisions </4 </4 :beer: </4 </4
-
Its not possible but I've tried 3 starters and 2 flywheels and now a diferent bellhousing. So what other serious problems can there be?
Sometimes the energy required to get the starter to work is more.
-
Ps thought it was the cable and changed that too
-
Oh and bettery is new as of about three months ago, Bosch battery as thought it might do better than a Halfrauds one
-
Earth strap was replaced about 6 months ago and stainess nuts and washers used to fix to to body.
Also done quite a bit of work on connectors to try solve indicator slowing issues however seems I am not the only one who has this so that seems normal
-
Have you checked that there is 12v on the small wire that connects to the solenoid when you turn the ignition to the start position ???
Hi Pete,
I have not tested it as i have no testing kit.
I could test it by simply running it to one of the rear light bulbs.
I did replace the female connector at the solenoid end as it fell off in my hand when i first noticed the problem.
Where does this wire run from? Is it from the ignition barrel?
I bought a new solenoid from 126fan so i cant see it being that the solenoid is afulty.
Any and all help appreciated.
I hope i can get this fixed befor the snow storms catch me.
-
Hi Neil, Just can't believe that a fiat 126 owner hasn't got a 12v circuit tester :D the best 3 quid you'll ever spend [-/
The wire runs to the ignition switch and then to the fuse box, If you have a short piece of heavy duty wire about 10cm long you can short it across the large terminal (which is a permanent live) to the solenoid terminal for a few seconds, this should activate the solenoid and the starter motor should turn. If it turns the problem is the wire back to the ignition switch, Or the Ignition switch itself. Beware Make sure the car is in neutral before you do this We don't want you running yourself over :D If you take the air filter box off you can reach these terminals from the top [-/
-
just as a little detour from the main point of the thread but... i kept snapping starter cables so i bought some steel wire rope from a diy superstore along with some mini clamps and then fabricated a super strong starter cable it never broke and it did not suffer from stretch....just a thought. i agree with pete sounds like the wiring has gone wrong somewhere can you take the starter off and bench test it?
-
Problem solved.
This thread should have been titled " what happens when you recondition a starter motor and don't put it back together properly."
Having taken the motor out and bench tested it like you suggested i noticed that the dog gear on the starter was not travelling the full distance to the end of the shaft.
It turned out that when reassembling the starter i put the plastic fork lever in upside down.
Nothing to do with the solenoid, it was working perfectly well.
It is all making sense now.
One thing that did disapoint me was the fact that when removing the brand new solenoid from the motor the plastic casing fractured and broke into a hand full of pieces.
At least the car now starts as it should.
4 hours spent messing about on the frozen ground.
Expecting more snow tommorrow.