Club126UK
Fiat 126 Chat => Fiat 126 Mechanical Problem Solving => Topic started by: kitten75 on August 06, 2010, 04:04:46 PM
-
Hi all
Right, my mechanic has said my Fiat needs a new engine due to the damage caused when the valve went. It doesn't need the auxiliary parts such as starter or carburrettor however it does need the main engine block. He can get a brand new one from Fiat for £650 but having only bought the car 3 weeks ago for £750 (think I was done!) I'm not sure I want/can afford to spend this...?
Would it be wiser in the longer term to buy a new engine or try to find a good condition second hand engine?
All advice appreciated!
Mhairi
-
Not sure if you're aircooled or water but this link has all the parts for the 126, but its in Germany not sure how much shipping would be, but i would think it will be cheaper than from Fiat, may find some thing in UK as well. Look in the for sale items too on the forum too
http://www.fiatclassic.com/HTML126/KATA126U.HTM#engine
-
Again not sure what type of engine but saw this on ebay
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/FIAT-126-ENGINE-/180540659011?cmd=ViewItem&pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item2a090fd543#ht_500wt_1182
-
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/FIAT-500-126-650cc-USED-CYLINDER-HEAD-/190415036641?cmd=ViewItem&pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item2c559ee0e1#ht_1064wt_941 [-/
-
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/FIAT-500-126-650cc-USED-CRANKCASE-/200492759624?cmd=ViewItem&pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item2eae4cba48#ht_1064wt_941 [-/
-
I am pretty sure she's after a Bis engine going by her old threads.
Ask your mechanic what's wrong with the block? it may be that the pistons have been damaged? if that is the case fair enough you will need a replacement engine.
If the block is ok a replacement cylinder head is your best option.
-
i think £650 is good for an engine from fiat. it would give your car a new lease of life.
-
I am pretty sure she's after a Bis engine going by her old threads.
Ask your mechanic what's wrong with the block? it may be that the pistons have been damaged? if that is the case fair enough you will need a replacement engine.
If the block is ok a replacement cylinder head is your best option.
Opps :oops:
-
I am sure you will find a used Bis engine for little money. In fact look in the for sale section on here there is a Bis for sale with 2 free engines thrown in. I am sure they would sell an engine.
-
I can`t see why you would need a new engine unless the damage is serious. The other thing, is the £650 for the whole engine, or just the block? Plus if you put labour on top of that the final price would be mad.
Maybe it would be wort talking to Jan-in-uk, or one of the Polish guys on here. I`m sure I saw some new bis engines-blocks on Alegro, or just go for a complete second hand one as already suggested.
Hope you get it sorted somehow!
-
cheers for all the advice...i'm taking my other car down to mechanic tomorrow as he's got a potential buyer for it as need to sell it to repair the Fiat. I'll speak to him tomorrow to get some more info on engine status and i am going to get a total cost including labour before i make a decision.
I am erring toward just biting the bullet and forking out for the new engine (should labour charge not be too bad) as Robin says, it'll give my car a new lease of life and as I know so little (ie. nothing) about cars it may be better for me in the long run. I don't want to buy a 2nd hand engine plus shipping for £100/200 etc and then have numerous repairs on top of that..even though keeping costs as low as poss at the minute is very appealing.
I see the chap that was doing the Mongolian race thing bought a 2nd hand engine for £600!
I'll get some more info tomorrow from Robert (mechanic) and see what he thinks.
It's a BIS enginer, water cooled I'm looking for...
thanks again, it's good to know there are folk out there who understand what i'm going through! I miss my little car!!
Mhairi
-
Amazing....I had a great BIS with a great engine and struggled to get £200 for it ::)
-
£600 for a second hand engine is definitely too much. You can sometimes buy a whole bis for less than that. You have to do your research first and add all the costs up to weigh up things. Ask Rusty how it can go even with a brand new bis :-X
-
God, now you're really scaring me..I assume rusty had a nightmare with a new BIS engine??
-
There were problems with the BIS when it came out. I think the ones that survived were sorted-out.
The one thing I learnt was they were prone to overheating. This is apparently due to the thermostat being far away from the head. Ricambio had a conversion to move it closer to the head. I simply removed the thermostat as thermostats can stick in the closed position therefore making it overheat.
Basically nothing should go wrong even with a standard BIS provided maintenance is strictly adhered to however in the real world, that is never the case, thus sticking thermostats will e the end of many a BIS engine.
I'm a little confused with yours, as the valve I assume failed to be the thermostat, which would simply need a head gasket replacement. A horrid little job to do but very do-able even for a relatively novice mechanic. A light skim of the head might be advisable. Not trying to second-guess you mechanic, but what possibly could have gone wrong to kill valve spring etc etc and require a new block even!
-
thanks Darrell - no problem in second guessing mechanic, I haven't got a clue what went wrong but i'm going to find out tomorrow morning. all he's said to me so far is that when the valve went it caused a lot of damage - but that could mean anything?
I'm pretty confused with all this thermostat, block, head gasket chat and not sure what questions I should be asking!
I wish someone could translate to my mechanic for me!! I've been using him for years as have had quite a lot of cars in my time (most with a life span of about 12 months!) so I know he won't be taking the p##' but it would still be good to be able to understand what has gone wrong and if I do definitely need a new engine before making any decision.
Mhairi
-
I guess it is best to go with your mechanic.
Try write down the technical details of what went wrong and we can try give our 5p worth one how to make sure it doesnt happen again.
Good luck, hope the car isn't a non-runner for long :o
-
Thanks - will just be sad tomorrow and take notes when he's going over what went wrong! On the plus side he thinks he's got a buyer for my Peugeot so i'll be able to buy the Fiat a new air freshener and bumper sticker at the very least!
watch this space tomorrow for my hilarious description of what is actually wrong!
Mhairi
-
I`m not trying to scare you! I think Darrell explained it a bit better. You need to get to the bottom of things first, to understand what happened, and than make preventions to minimise the chance of it happening again as the bis engines do suffer with overheating.
I hope it gets sorted one way, or the other as you like the car so much [-/
-
I run an aircooled engine.
I took the engine out to rebuilt and re-fitted a 500cc (£50), didn't realise it was loosing oil through the main bearing while running and sezied it. I then bought another 2nd hander for £80 from a guy on a farm. Emgine hasn't let me down since.
If you buy a new engine, the head gasket might bloe.
If you buy a second hand engine, the head gasket might blow, but it will have cost you far less money. A new engine won't sort out the poor water flow of a bis engine, but we are all here to offer help whenever you need it.
Michael
-
Right, bear with me whilst i try to explain...had long discussion with Robert (mechanic) and he showed me my little car with engine in bits, boo, but to be honest it was over 12 hours ago and I'm struggling to remember - should have taken my notepad, oops.
what I can remember is that one of the springs on one of the valves completely disintegrated whilst i was driving and that's what he said has caused the damage. the little nut type things that bolt the valves to the 'rocker feet' had also broken. He didn't think this any of the damage was due to overheating, he just said he thought I was unlucky! he said he would be wary of rebuilding the existing engine as there's a danger in rebuilding the top half of the engine and not the bottom half, and then a problem occurs in the bottom half and then they aren't in harmony>! Please excuse this - not his exact words and like i say I never took notes so if it doesn't make sense then blame me! Maybe I'll get Robert to join the forum and he can be my 'voice'!.
I explained to him all the points everyone has raised about the design fault and problems with BIS engines overheating etc however he kind of agreed with what everyone has said so far in that - it's risk you've got take if you want to drive a 126!
On further investigation there was an invoice in the log book from 1994 (car is a 1990) and the engine was rebuilt then for some reason...again Robert said he would be concerned about rebuilding the engine given that it had £700 worth of work done on it 4 years after registration?
he's going to do a local part search for a 2nd hand engine and let me know Tuesday if he's come up with anything that he thinks is decent, failing that new engine from Fiat it will have to be. Labour is looking like £200-300 so all in worst case scenario i'm looking at £1k - oops. Also found the purchase invoice for the car and it was bought for £1300 back in the day so i've already spent more than it was originally bought for...! Just as well i totally love my little car...
Took my ever faithful Peugeot to him today and told him whatever money he sells it for to put on my account for the Fiat! Fingers crossed he sells it quickly...sad to see it go even though it was a 1998, never had a problem with it in the whole 5 years i've owned it. somehow i don't think i'll be saying that again...
Mhairi
-
Just my observation from what you wrote: valve springs can break but rarely. The air cooled engines have 2 springs, don't know in the BIS, but that's why there are 2 springs so that if 1 breaks the other spring won't let the valve fall in. He didn't mention anything about the timing chain breaking?
If the block isn't badly worn, damaged (e.g. cracked) then i don't see why it has to be replaced. If the pistons aren't damaged (even then you can replace the pistons and the piston rings, worse if you have to replace the conrods too) then you may just need a new cylinder head or have the cylinder head repaired. (Just my opinion)
-
there was only one large spring on each valve. No mention of timing chain breaking. I did ask if I could get away with just a head gasket repair but that's when he said he didn't like to rebuild the top half of the engine and not the bottom at the same time?
I meant to ask if the engine block was ok but forgot...was trying to remember all the earliers posts and points raised without pulling out my iphone and reading the comments to him!
M
-
Buy a second hand engine off ebay and put it in yourself, 1K is too much to have yours repaired proberbly be good though if it's done! Mine went so got a second hand one for £75 put it in and never looked back has been great!
-
Buy a second hand engine off ebay and put it in yourself, 1K is too much to have yours repaired proberbly be good though if it's done! Mine went so got a second hand one for £75 put it in and never looked back has been great!
Got to agree, but if you cant due to know how then so be it O0 £1000 then you will be back on the road to enjoy the rest of the summer O0 O0 O0
-
Shame you are not nearer otherwise I would love to help!
-
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Fiat-126-Bis-Engine-with-carb-/260645712452?cmd=ViewItem&pt=UK_CarsParts_Vehicles_CarParts_SM&hash=item3cafb1f244
Long way to go though but only £10
-
thanks Ciaoflyer...i wish you were closer too so you could help! re engine for a tenner...why is it so cheap when all the other engines on Ebay are hundreds of pounds?? anyway, can't get to Kent to pick it up so it's a no go. I'll see if Robert is able to source a 2nd hand one tomorrow...
m
-
I recon if you ask the seller to courier it to you he might be tempted, make it worth his while [-/
The diference is trade versus a private sale. The trade put things at a price they think they can sell them for, and when you desparate, you pay...
-
"was told engine was running at time of removal" - there's no guarantee the engine is in full working order so it would be tenner plus courier of about £100 or so - bit risky?
m
-
I recon £110 would give your mechanic enough to get it back on the road no?
Worth a go and the spares would always come-in useful [-/
-
do you mean he uses the parts from the tenner engine to rebuild my existing or would he replace my existing engine with the cheap one and hope for the best>!
-
Once you get the engine, the mechanic can check it out and make that decision. It might be fine. Could be my old engine as my car went to Kent :oops:
-
Tenner engine from Kent is no go as the rude ebay seller (hope he's not on this forum!) sent me a curt message saying he wouldn't be prepared to courier it and it is for collection only. Just found out Robert (mechanic) has buggered off on his holibags for a fortnight leaving my little car, engineless in his workshop! I hope Fiat don't sell their 3 new engines before he gets back!!
mhairi
-
he wouldn't be prepared to courier it and it is for collection only.
Have a look at ebay or shiply for courier companies.
shiply has a bidding system where you upload a description of what you need, then courier companies or individuals will bid agaisnt each other to offer the lowest price, I have used this twice with success, low price quotes land at your feet.
Also retro rides has a bulletin board for people travelling up and down the country willing to collect and drop off items.
I would recomend you exhaust this route before you buy a new engine. That is alot of money.
If you have had a quote for approx £1k for new engine and fitting then it's probably more cost effective to sell this car as a project requiring a new engine and buy another one. I know this sounds emotionless, but you would still end up with a working 126!