Club126UK
Fiat 126 Chat => Tuning & Customising 126 Models => Topic started by: Rusty's Uncle on July 21, 2010, 07:41:11 PM
-
OK , Oil Coolers , starting to get interested, so what's that all about then, crazy ideas going around my head & need someone to bring me back down to earth ::)
-
hot oil goes in gets cooled and goes round the engine gets heated again goes into the cooler again gets cool again goes into .... thats the tech talk over hope it helps.
-
Bis man , I told you to stop playing with your fundamentals , you will go blind :oops:
I know that what goes up must come down & that E equals MC squared :oops:
You ain't helped my crazy ideas :cry:
Still love you though ;)
-
I'm sure Steve will explain the technical bits, but Mick explained it very well lol.
Here's a picture of the adapter on Steve's engine ;D
-
My thinking also Pete although Mick does have a way of explaining things in simple terms :oops:
First question is ............. Is it possible to just tap into the existing threaded points on the crankcase , if so which ones ???
-
I want that one [-/
-
Rusty I was told to drill a hole in the oil pump casing and block off the flow through the drive spindle this diverts the flow through the hole in the casing. You weld on an adapter, can ba bought from all suppliers. The oil then flows from the pump through the new line to the oil cooler it then return to the allan bolt just above and to the right of the oil pump, again a screw in addapter is required to screw into the block. I was told this from an old Italian 500 abarth engine builder. It is a lot cheaper than purchasing the market conversions.
-
I tried to get that allen bolt out, it isnt playing ball, it's almost as though it was cast into the casing :oops:
-
in the german 500forum a part of owners tend not to touch the circulating oil of the engine.
They take the oil from the sump, then lead it to the cooler with an extern pump and lead it back to the sump. That helps lowering the temperature to about 90-100°C.
Someone told me, a petrol pump of an Mercedes W123 would be ideal for that.
look here: (ok, it's in german. But the pictures are quite good) ;)
http://willsagen.de/?page_id=307
-
Well my interest was raised by just having had the fan blow & the subsequent massive over heating although an oil cooler would not have helped much in that situation. Been in touch with the www.126fan.com guys and they say that the standard fan will disintegrate around 6,000 rpm . They only run oil coolers on their hill climb cars and the larger alloy sumps on fast road race motors. The 500 / 126 engine has the built in oil cooler with some of the fan air being directed down along the bottom of the sump vents. With the little connector piece between fan housing & sump removed I was amazed at the volome of air being pushed down there. With the connector on not much of that cooling air was being blown through. Combination of damage to base of sump plus build up of crud in the vent channels. Worth checking out if you are running an aircooled. [-/
-
thats definately got me thinking, although If I were to fit an oil cooler, I'd prefer to fit a can filter in there somewhere too.
It might seem a bit like overkilll, but the little engines do cook oil quite well when they want to!
-
HI guys
Check out the systems as used on a production car such as some Lancia and 130TC Fiat. They run a bypass system with a built in thermostat so that the hot oil only flows through the cooler after it reaches a certain temperature. Remote filter systems are available as I have fitted them to rally cars. The problem that I see is that if the oil runs through the cooler all the time then the engine will take longer to come up to temp in winter. But then in NZ we don't know what that is like. The next question is where to mount the cooler radiator.
Allan
-
oh yes, it should not run all the time...
just use a switch for the pump. If you see the oil getting hot: switch on. If cool enough: off That's what the pilot of an 126 surely can do... :P
-
When the oil has done it's lubrication job it returns to the sump via two slots in the crankcase at the flywheel end of the motor. It must still have some pressure at that point. Would it be possible to divert the returning oil by putting a fitting in the sump and blocking the little piece in the sump where the oil would normally flow and then put it through the cooler and back to the sump.
Allan
-
Would it be possible to divert the returning oil by putting a fitting in the sump and blocking the little piece in the sump where the oil would normally flow and then put it through the cooler and back to the sump.
Allan
There are several ways to use the existing pump to feed the oil cooler, but the concern is whether the extra force required to pump through the pipes and cooler are likely to put the oil pump under strain.
if the flow is altered then it is likely that it will lower the oil pressure. pumping oil down the pipes will cause a drop in pressure, not including the cooler.
Also, there will be a much greater strain on the pump at cold before the oil warms up.
An electric pump offers a switch or thermostat control and if fitted correctly, will not disrupt the internal oil flow.
The links Alfons posted earlier show a very neat oil cooler install on a 500roughly where the petrol tank on a 126 sits the other side of the car would work if fitting it to a 126
-
Would it be possible to divert the returning oil by putting a fitting in the sump and blocking the little piece in the sump where the oil would normally flow and then put it through the cooler and back to the sump.
Allan
Hi, interesting debate,
I tyred several ways to fit an oil cooler and as pics above show ended up with adapting the cam drive cover. Allan the only problem with the rear bearings oil return is you will not get as much oil flow as required and as pressure builds up to push the oil through the oil pipes and rad this pressure will be on the rear oil seal, not good.
Micheal is also right that the oil required to push through the oil cooler is not regulated until it gets to the pressure releaf valve after the oil has returned to the engine, I was concerned with this so done some maths and reconed the blanking plug thats required to block the pump i drilled a 3mm hole to releif the extreme pressure. Also as you now run the oil cooler you can use a synthetic oil of thinner viscousity.
[-/
Sweat 8)
-
So my thoughts so far </3
The standard 50+ year old design on the aircooled engine is fine but a good idea to check that the air flow passages are clear. tuning the engine requires an uprated fan that is the heart of the whole cooling system. The idea of a seperate pumped thermostaticaly controlled oil cooling system is interesting but a bit over the top for me as the beauty of the engine is the simplicity. My "crazy" idea might be to fit the larger sump then alter the base of the fan housing so the cooling air directed there is blown through an oil cooler. Use the shortest pipe runs possible to minimise any pressure loss ;D
-
A very interesting debate. I'm beginning to think that a totally independant system with its own pump is the way to go. This leaves the engine system working as it was designed to do. If you used the right pump you could also fit a remote filter to the system. Also you could fit a temp switch to turn the pump on when the temp reached a certain level. I would take the oil from below the rear main outlet and return it at a point very close to the oil pick up. Next question is "what about a dry sump set up"?
Allan
-
Hmmm 126s and electics...i dunno...
Had electric windows, didnt work out binned them, put brighter bulbs in on relays and if you're not careful the battery goes flat on idle.
40psi through a bit of hose, through an oil cooler, it isn't going to suffer much losses at all in pressure. After all the flow isn't huge. If a hole in my rear bearing can drop the pressure then the flow must be small. Thermostatic control..why not simply take a leaf out of the fiat book and simply fit a flap to the oil cooler and duct the air through it.
Rusty's idea of the oil cooler picking-up air off the bottom feed to the sump has merit I think. A simple flap on this would mean in the dead of winter you're not loosing too much heat. The flap would direct more air for the heater [-/
A Bis would be better-off with the electric version as they have better electics.
That's my 5p worth :oops:
-
Do you want to discuss dry sumps here or on another thread?
Allan
-
I think the VW Beetle air cooled engines have a factory oil cooler as mentioned before, the fan blows air through it.
-
But that would mean the air arriving to cool the engine would already have some extra heat to it. Another byproduct of running an oil cooler is the additional oil capacity.
Allan
-
The more I think about it the more I like the idea of a remote fitted oil cooler. I agree with Uncle Rusty in leaving the motor as designed and built by Fiat. My thoughts as I have said would be to take the oil via a fitting in the sump from near the return slots at the rear main bearing and return it via another fitting with an extension inside the sump placing the cooled oil very close to the oil pickup. Both fittings could quite easily fit on the left side of the sump (side opposite the exhaust). Picking up from and returning this way would mean that should you no longer require the cooling system the only part you need to replace is the sump.
I have just looked at my engine compartmant and the logical place for the pump is in the recess on the left side. Mine even has two 6mm studs there on which to mount it. Which only leaves the most important part, the radiator. My first thought is to mount this somewhere in the front edge of the motor compartment just behind the fuel tank but clear of the left rear suspension. Another area is on the rear cross member although this may be in an area of negative air pressure and a third is on the left side on an angle.
This brings another problem. You would need to ensure that oil in the cooler radiator and lines did not return to the sump when the pump was not running hense overfilling the sump with oil. For this you would need the fitting of at least one non return valve. If you really felt the need to you could always run an additional tank in the system to give you greater oil capacity and therefore in theory at least greater cooling.
Someone may like to enlighten us as to the size, capacity and type of pump required to perform this task.
Keep the thoughts coming.
Allan
-
What's the point of a dry sump?
I dunno think thats modifying things a little too far..
-
My dry sump suggestion is a little tongue in cheek. However a few years back when I was into flying small aircraft I visited the air show at Oshkosh in Wisconcin USA where they showed a Subaru motor that was dry sumped but did not run a scavange pump. The explanation given was that the were using the positive crankcase pressure to return the oil to the tank. The one thing we got plenty of in our engines is positive crankcase pressure.
And further to my post on oil coolers one point I omitted to discuss was the flow rate and how to get it right. If we force the oil through the radiator too fast then we will get very little cooling effect and if too slow and over cool the oil run the risk of shock cooling the engine.
Some one who has more experience in these matters might like to comment.
Allan
-
Rusty you started a riot with this thread you naughty boy, :P
Now fiat fitted a baffled tin sump to blow cool air across it to help with engine temperatures and when they did this it must have raised manufacturing cost, so from this they must have known that there engines got close to the high end of the spectrum that oils back then would cope with, after all a sump has cool air around it when the car is moving. Now as the engine got bigger and roads got faster and people travelled further then it must stand to reason an oil cooler will be required as you cannot cool the engine by fitting a bigger water radiator with engine size as would be the case with a liquid cooled car.
Now Mr naughty boy your talking about 800cc and with this brings more heat not only from thermal conbustion but also bigger frictional service area from pistons which is going to raise the oil temparetures when travelling at 70mph on the motorway.
Life would be wonderful if you could just tap in to the oil flow and return it but this is not possible but you know this already Rusty and if you did would possibly upset the oil pressure/flow within the engine. Now as mentioned a seperated aux elec pump would do the job put is expensive and complex and we don't like that on here. >:(
Now as puddlejumper shown if you tap somehow into the oil pump cover then return it to the blanking plug just right to the pump (yes they never come out Darrell so drill and tap) then you will not upset the oil pressure within the engine because until it get to this point it has not been pressure regulated to 40psi [-/are we happy so far.
Now if 7mm bore hose is used then flowrate will not be affected unless you use miles off the stuff. ;D. So the only thing left is the heat exchanger, if to small will retrict flow and to big may drop oil temp to much, a 10 row cooler will properly be ok and you can cover 50% off it in the winter to stop over cooling. As mentioned also thermal shocking components by quenching with cold oil is not going to be an issue with a system like this as you bring the oil temp up as soon as you start the engine from cold unlike a aux pump that might kick in on demand once oil temp has got above happy temparetures. Also an additional remote oil filter can be placed in the system.
Now Rusty are you still interested?
Love you still. Smallcox [-/
-
If knowledge is power, then smallcox must be well on his way to world domination by now!
-
:D :D Now look here Small "yellow peril" cox if you are so damn clever how come I can only get 100 giga wattts out of my flux capacitor ;D ;D
How did I know that you would have calculated those flow rates & hence the optimum hose bore size ;)
Must have been old gits intuition :o
I was not thinking particularly about the 795 ccs engine but just ideas for "cool runnings" on any slightly modified engine. I think that a well maintained standard engine can be well thrashed and give a very good life considering the age of the design etc. Just like the contempory competition in Europe at that time Citroen 2CV , VW Beetle & the Morris Minor.
That blown air under the sump must be quite a volume at high revs but the sump design is from the 50's so not efficient and motorway driving was not invented.
After all these cars were designed in Italy and are famous for being driven hard. Seems like we are getting there but got to go back on the naughty step now :oops:
-
probably you need something like this: http://www.ilmotore.de/shop/index.php/cat/c3_oil-cooler.html
besides, I would tend to use an external system with a separate pump. For this I will use display for temperature and a simple switch with control lamp.
(http://s7.directupload.net/images/100727/temp/ge63wq8a.jpg) (http://s7.directupload.net/file/d/2233/ge63wq8a_jpg.htm)
If to hot, I'll switch on, if cold I switch off. I try to use used parts to keep the costs low.
My sump already has these plug-and-play-connections, a heritage of the seventies:
(http://s7.directupload.net/images/100727/temp/ilf8s2vg.jpg) (http://s7.directupload.net/file/d/2233/ilf8s2vg_jpg.htm)
-
Nice looking gear but I couldn't get it to talk to me in a language I understand. I'm with those who are going for the external set up and leaving the motor alone. This way we are adding to the cooling without asking the motor to do any additional work. Poor little thing works hard enough as it is especially the way some of us drive. The whole idea Dave is to allow us to give them more of a thrashing.
Regards to you all.
Allan
p.s. Loved the photos of the meeting.
-
Come on people, think outside the box.
Gotta love this thread,
In the red corner we have the externally assisted 'oil coolers'
In the blue corner we have the internally assisted 'oil coolers'
Introducing the pink corner - the 'heatsink'
This thread made me think of it. Why not use a large heatsink to cover the sump. I was looking at an old Alpine amp i have in my shed and thought - that amp cover/heatsink would look good as a fake ribbed sump under my niki. Then thoughts of this thread came to my head and of the possible oil cooling effectiveness of a heatsink. Seeing as fiat regard a small flap directed to the sump as adeqate, the heatsink's large surface area should do something if attached to the sump. The cover is huge, it measures 30x20cm and has sexy angled ribbed wings on either side.
Its simple-just bolt it up, cheap-you can buy old 80's amps with those massive heatsink bodies for nothing, effective-seeing how much heat even a small heatsink fitted to a computer can cope with, it should provide results, also effectiveness/wind speed should also increase as road speed increases, and most of all, very sexy-i'll paint it up red and polish the ribs and i'll have my Spanky Replica Abarth Race Sump.
Sorry - had too many JD&C's tonight
Let the riot continue..............
-
no, gsxr,
I think your idea is good. Why not? It's cheap and probably very effective. Most effective it will be when paintet. the colour does not mention. It is just because bright aluminium has a low emission coefficent. About 0,1. Paintet it will be about 0,9. that will increase the thermal radiation.
I'd like to have some additional colling at the cylinder head. is it possible to mount some heatsinks there? Probably beneath the tin housing?
-
C'mon now GSXR126. But not the worst idea in the world.
Why JD&C. What wrong with Bundy?
Allan
-
Alfons, i suppose anywhere is possible, its just a matter of bolting one on. We'll see how good the idea is. I'll try to get this done over the next few weeks and post some pics. I should probably hook up an oil temp gauge now and compare later.
Allan, thats Queensland sh*t, rough as guts and always gives you a sore noggin in the morning. I'll stick to my smooth sippin whiskey thanks.
Back to oil coolin. I'm sure you have all considered or realised that the main issue here is what we are actually cooling - the oil, but no one has yet to mention the advances in oil technology and what that means for our little engines. Any oil's stability will decrease with repeated heat cycles but i think the more modern oils/synthetics stay stable for longer. The right grade is available for our engines in mineral and synthetic, the trick is finding the right additives to ensure suitablity.
The right oil with the right additives and regular servicing should eliminate the need for any type of oil cooler on a standard engine - fake or not.
-
but you should not use oil with additives, because of our not existing oil filter. If there are cleansing additives, they will loosen the dirt in the spin filter and transport it to the bearings where the can lead to heavy engine failure. That's not amusing... :o
But what you can use is an oil 20W-50 instead of 15W-40
What has to be mentioned you usually change the oil every 3.000 miles (or so), so the stability is not our biggest problem, I think.
-
yeah thats the trick - finding the 'RIGHT' additives. I agree with you on the cleansing additive. i think its called PFPE and you need to have to right amount in your oil - i think.
The owners manual states that anywhere from 10W to 50 mutigrade oil can be used. Just depends on your climate.
Ive done 13,500 klms in my daily driver so far and have done two oil changes and i am happy with the oil i'm using. Its Nulon 15W-50 Synthetic. What i have noticed is the oil is a lot cleaner when its due for a change (every 5000klm) and its getting cleaner every change.
An oil's stabilty is basically its film strength and film strength is directly affected by heat and pressure so i would consider this as vital to maintaining correct oil conditions
-
I'm ordering two ten row coolers, as soon as I've seen smallcox's car in person.
Just need the exact details on the drilling into the oil pump, drill and taping the return seems no bother.
Tried and tested the world over, i see an external filter is available so probably go that route too [-/