Club126UK

Fiat 126 Chat => Fiat 126 Chat => Topic started by: dadandlad on January 03, 2016, 01:07:00 PM

Title: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on January 03, 2016, 01:07:00 PM
During the rebuild of my Bis I have there is a lot of sub standard parts out there so thought I would start a thread on the parts I have had problems with

The worst problems have been with the front quarter light frames which took a lot of getting right including disassembly and re-riveting of the frames not good at £45.00 each

The door window trims with the window felt on them ended up in the bin after numerous attempts to fit, these were basically too big between the corner radius's and i found them impossible to rework

One of my favourites was the headlamp retaining clips which as soon as you lay eyes on them self explode, used four to get a usable one

I feel pretty certain you can add to this list     
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Piotross on January 03, 2016, 01:27:47 PM
problem with them ?

http://iv.pl/images/56101767674386814444.jpg
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on January 03, 2016, 04:16:40 PM
I haven't had any problems with the headlamp surrounds just the clips that secure the lamps to the adjusters

(http://i669.photobucket.com/albums/vv57/markm16/_12_zpswrss95cm.jpg) (http://s669.photobucket.com/user/markm16/media/_12_zpswrss95cm.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: cider on January 03, 2016, 09:34:46 PM
Yep Me too  >:(The ones from 126fan seems to be made of chocolate :D
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Piotross on January 03, 2016, 09:46:35 PM
Hehe I know this situation, I don't like to install them too ! The plastic is to hard and if you want to install it properly and safety then you have to heat them a little by dryer or put them in a hot water. They breaking so often.
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: cider on January 03, 2016, 09:54:37 PM
Thank you Piotr for the tip  :D :D I will give it ago

Cheers

Pete
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Gadge on January 04, 2016, 11:29:55 AM
Those silly plastic screw heads for the indicator lenses get me swearing  >:(
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: DeVilleChris on January 04, 2016, 12:06:54 PM
I'm with Mark.. The stupid aluminium door glass frame thingy..

That thing is such a pain!
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on January 04, 2016, 12:40:12 PM
Quote
Those silly plastic screw heads for the indicator lenses get me swearing

Forgot about them the heads are made of cheese
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Bambino126 on January 07, 2016, 05:00:36 PM
Removing and refitting the fuel tank!
Grrr!  >:(
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: mintex on January 07, 2016, 06:06:00 PM
Removing and refitting the fuel tank!
Grrr!  >:(

Dont say that as its a job i have to do lol  :P
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Gadge on January 08, 2016, 06:14:13 AM
Removing and refitting the fuel tank!
Grrr!  >:(

Ahhhhh yes that is a b*****d
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: mintex on January 08, 2016, 07:54:57 AM
Shhh, stop saying that .... haha :P
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: 1973/126 on January 08, 2016, 10:59:25 PM
 Oh a replacement fuel tank is a real joy. I had to bash the last one into place as it just wouldn`t fit :rant.
 
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Joe Webb on March 02, 2016, 01:29:59 AM
on the el and elx the wing mirror arms are made of chalk :/
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Yoshimisumi on March 12, 2016, 04:41:54 PM
Brake shoe springs...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Xylaquin on June 08, 2016, 09:26:29 AM
The door window trims with the window felt on them ended up in the bin after numerous attempts to fit, these were basically too big between the corner radius's and i found them impossible to rework

I'm with Mark.. The stupid aluminium door glass frame thingy..

That thing is such a pain!

Is it possible? I need to fit new outer frames, as I've had no outer weather strips for ages!
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on June 08, 2016, 03:38:08 PM
Quote
Is it possible? I need to fit new outer frames, as I've had no outer weather strips for ages!

The ones I purchased from Axel Gerrstl drove me mad trying to get them to fit, basically they are made wrong and because it is a U section without the correct formers you cannot re bend without them creasing.

I suppose you could try and remove the weatherstrip and attach to your old ones or cut a section out and butt the cut ends together

I ended up refitting my old ones which took me about 20 minutes after 3-4 hours messing with the new ones and throwing them in the bin

Good luck
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Xylaquin on June 09, 2016, 12:39:43 AM
Yeah...
[youtube]WkgjipGRqhQ[/youtube]
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: cider on June 09, 2016, 01:56:04 PM
Nasty, :o Did you get a refund
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Xylaquin on June 09, 2016, 02:59:32 PM
Doubt I have much chance with an ebayer over in Italy after taking a hammer to the thing too. I'll probably just try remove the weather strips and staple them onto my existing ones.

Although one of my existing ones is snapped into 4 pieces  ???
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: 1973/126 on June 20, 2016, 10:07:23 AM
 What`s starting to get to me is the quality of the parts more than anything.
 Few photos attached of the incident that happened to us yesterday.
 The drive shaft coupling has done less than 1000 mls. It`s completely had it. The now rusty looking hand brake cable was fitted at the same time as the coupling.
 (http://i885.photobucket.com/albums/ac53/Fiat-mad-lad/IMG_0382_zpszmtesqsz.jpg) (http://s885.photobucket.com/user/Fiat-mad-lad/media/IMG_0382_zpszmtesqsz.jpg.html)

 and the quality repair that got us home ;D
 (http://i885.photobucket.com/albums/ac53/Fiat-mad-lad/IMG_0380_zpssgewl8gg.jpg) (http://s885.photobucket.com/user/Fiat-mad-lad/media/IMG_0380_zpssgewl8gg.jpg.html)
 
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Rusty's Uncle on June 20, 2016, 12:09:34 PM
That is pretty awfull but that was a good bit of thinking with those 3 jubilee clips  :)
Did it get you home?
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on July 03, 2016, 06:00:57 PM
As stated by 1973/126 it is the quality of the parts that really annoys me

Stripped the head off the Bis today and can safely say the gasket kit purchased from Axel Gerstl is the cause of my problem
The head securing nuts had hardly any tension on them caused by what appears to be a gasket gone soggy for want of a better explanation
The head when built was torqued up correctly to the block,my torque wrench is accurate as it was calibrated shortly before doing the job
The engine has run a maximum of one hour and not travelled more than a mile never mind 500

I had noticed with the carb that it appeared to be loose when I came to remove previously tight nuts

The gaskets in the kit are made from a strange black material

Pretty bloody annoyed to say the least
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Gadge on July 03, 2016, 08:50:25 PM
The exact same thing happened to my old "green" engine, less than 1500 miles done and it blew even with waterless coolant and my best efforts to chase out air locks. I never took the head off to investigate but I suspected that the head nuts had come loose but a soggy gasket would've had the same effect :(
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on July 03, 2016, 10:47:38 PM
Quote
I suspected that the head nuts had come loose but a soggy gasket would've had the same effect

I am certain the nuts do not come loose on there own and have put it down to the gasket material itself.

It seems to keep on compressing once torqued down and the component ends up being loose
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: drcdb15 on July 04, 2016, 01:09:56 AM
It's a while since I torqued down a head  :$ but iirc don't you tighten when cold, and then again immediately the engine has warmed up, because the head bolts will naturally expand a fair bit with the temperature. I don't have precise figures to hand, but iirc steel has a cte of about 13 x10e-6 per degree. If a cold head is at 20 degC, and a hot one at 800 degC on the inside, let's say the temperature increase is about 600 C degrees.

How long is the head bolt? I don't know. Let's say it's about 150mm long. That would give an increase in length of 150 x 13 x 10e-6 x 600 mm = 1.17mm.

Again, I'm mentally on the back of a fag packet here, but if the thread pitch of the head bolt is about 1.25mm (which figure I seem to recall Ladislav gave me once for a wheel bolt!) that means the head nuts/bolts would need be tightened roughly a whole turn to get the same torque when the head is hot compared to when it's cold.

If you are only torquing the head when cold, and then assuming the next time you need do it is after 500 miles, then that might explain why the gasket is not sealing.

The "after 500 miles" requirement is to allow for stretching of the head bolts. If you imagine the bolt is tightened when hot, when it cools down again it wants to go back to being 150mm long. But the 'hot' torquing is forcing it to be under the same tension as if it was only 149mm long. Where does that extra mm go? It goes into the tension being applied to the bolt by the relatively incompressible cylinder head.

Like every other material, steel has a degree of stretchability, and after 500 miles the repeated cycling of hot and cold, tension applied (cold) and then relieved (hot) will likely have caused a permanent stretch in the head bolt, hence the need to re-check it is still holding the head on tightly enough to keep the gasket sealing.

All of this is especially important when the head bolts are new. As they age, not only does re-torquing stretch them, but the heat cycling also hardens the metal, making it more brittle and less prone to further stretching.

Now you folks are, I know, very experienced with these engines, so if I am telling you how to suck eggs I apologise - just hoping to help get to the bottom of the problem.
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Xylaquin on July 04, 2016, 10:01:13 AM
I'm replacing my headgasket with what appears to be a genuine OEM BIS headgasket.

Are you saying the process is fit the gasket, torque it all back together cold then

A) Run the car till warm, then retorque
or
B) Run the car till 500 miles, then retorque
or
C) Both!
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: drcdb15 on July 04, 2016, 12:40:46 PM
Well, in my younger days I would have said "C". However, technology moves on, and torquing sequences today are set by engine makers, head bolt/stud makers, and even by the gasket makers - take your pick, they all have specifc recommendations.

My calculations were off the top of my head. On further reflection, the thermal expansion of the bolts is exacerbated, as I said, by them stretching, but is counteracted by the expansion of the cylinder head, which being aluminium probably expands more than the steel bolts - however, this is complex, since a long thin bolt will in practice expand almost entirely longitudinally, whereas a large block like a cylinder head will expand almost isotropically. The figure I used for the steel expansion is the *linear* cte.

Anyway, the net outcome is that some combinations of head/bolt/gasket are designed to be torqued cold, then hot, whilst others should only be done cold.

Then there are TTY bolts, which are meant to be torqued 'half way', as it were, then left to settle for a few hours (to settle after stretching), then torqued again, and maybe even a third time.

You might find this item instructive (or desperately confusing!):

http://www.enginebuildermag.com/2005/07/perfect-engine-sealing-starts-with-proper-head-bolt-use/

If you google 'torque head bolts hot or cold' you will get loads of debate on the subject, but for relevance to classic cars this thread seems typical:
http://www.oldclassiccar.co.uk/forum/phpbb/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=10967&sid=15b87ad5becef4c2babc9bdd7717c5dc

Consensus seems to be torquing hot was necessary for iron head engines (shows my age!!), but not advised for alloy heads. What *IS* common to all is that the torque should be checked several times when the head is replaced, to compesnate for stretching of the bolts and compression of the gasket. It seems if you just torque the bolts once during assembly and think "that's it", you will likely have the problems our friends have encountered.

It might be sensible to check the official Fiat factory workshop manual for your model to see what procedure Fiat themselves recommend.
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: drcdb15 on July 04, 2016, 12:47:55 PM
Well, I've just checked the Fiat manual on this site for the air-cooled, and all it gives is the sequence and the torque setting. So not a lot of help. It is implied that it is set cold, simply because other operations follow in sequence, and there is no explicit mention of warming the engine before torquing.
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on July 04, 2016, 06:09:42 PM
I have changed loads of head gaskets from single cylinder whizz pops to  Detroit 2 stroke twin turbo supercharged V8 s and never had this problem before

I stand by my diagnosis of cheap crappy gasket made of Dairylea CHEESE  ;D

On a more serious note I am going to machine a new set of head washers with a recess to accommodate a O-Ring which should eliminate any chance of water creeping up and around the head studs and into the rocker cover
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Xylaquin on July 04, 2016, 06:10:54 PM
I drive a BIS, and the handbook mentions you get a free service coupon then lists what is included in that service. Notably the first item is "cylinder head bolt torque".
The service should be done "after 600-900 miles".
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: dadandlad on July 04, 2016, 06:21:15 PM
Quote
Notably the first item is "cylinder head bolt torque".
The service should be done "after 600-900 miles".

I haven't even done a mile  :o 
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Bambino126 on July 08, 2016, 08:49:12 PM
I have never had the head off my Bis, but last time I had the rocker cover off to check the valve clearances I decided to check the head bolt tightness.

All bolts needed a quarter turn at least to make the torque wrench click. My car has 60,000 miles on.
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: cider on July 09, 2016, 02:51:57 PM
Quote from: dadandlad 

I stand by my diagnosis of cheap crappy gasket made of Dairylea CHEESE  ;D


[/quote

Yep any of the Black/grey gaskets used on the water Jacket will leak so best to use as a pattern
on 1mm gasket paper
Title: Re: Parts that make you swear
Post by: Xylaquin on November 20, 2016, 04:40:00 PM
the rear panel of a BIS and the absolute pain it is to put it back on. Particularly the nuts on the radiator side.

Why couldn't they mount it some other place, bah.